Fly Fishing Experts
Return to all Experts Articles

Fly Fishing Jazz: Bonding with the Ax

by Kirk Deeter
Fly Fishing Spey RodSpey Mission. Photo Tibor Nemeth

I DON’T KNOW why more fly fishers don’t fall in love with a single rod and stick with it forever.

My tackle retailer and manufacturer friends will hate me for saying that, but I think it’s an interesting and worthwhile question to consider.

It seems to me that fly fishers are swept up in the marketing hype—the faster, further, stronger hyperbole—more than any other demographic this side of your local golf course. Yet in truth, if ever there were a sport where finding a trusted tool one can master with aplomb can pay dividends for decades, it’s fly fishing.

The music analogies: Willie Nelson is inseparable from a ratty old Martin N-20 (nylon string) guitar he named “Trigger” after Roy Rogers’ horse. Clapton’s most famous guitar is a Fender Stratocaster named “Blackie.” B.B. King’s legendary “Lucille” is a Gibson ES 335. John Coltrane made his best music with a Selmer Mark VI tenor sax. It’s the bonds between the players and the instruments that make the trademark sounds.

Of course, there have been many incarnations of “signature” instruments, and it’s ultimately the style of the player that dictates the distinctive tone. (Mark Knopfler’s sound comes from the finger style, the thumb instead of the pick—but he still adheres to the tones found on Stratocasters and Telecasters to find his music.)

But why are we so eager to switch on a whim? Is it lack of confidence? Marketing hypnosis?

Actually, my wife’s grandfather (who taught me a lot about fly fishing) bucked that trend (before it was a trend). We could give him a new, fancy rod as a birthday or Christmas present, and he’d smile and act thankful. But when he went to the river, it was always the same, old Orvis 8-foot 5-weight, with an oddly oversized cork handle that he liked to fish. The man knew what he wanted.

Truth is (and I’m not complaining about this by any stretch), as a magazine writer, I’m sent “new generation” fly rods to test every year. The rod companies want me to write about them. And I do. And, based on what I write, many of you buy those rods.

But when I go out and fish for trout on my own, for fun and no strings attached, I find myself, more often than not, packing the same 5-weight I got years ago. I call it “Old Betsy” (after Davy Crockett’s rifle), and she’s never let me down. Never broken. And I never felt like I missed a fish, or made a bad cast because of the rod. The brand and model are irrelevant. The point is, everyone has an “ax,” and the real test is to find it, live with it, fish it, make your own music, and go from there.

Sure there are reasons to spread the love—a 5-weight for trout, an 8-weight for bonefish, a bass rod, a tarpon rod… all wonderful. All good.

But there’s something very special, even admirable, about finding a rod that you make friends with, that becomes part of your fishing persona, and sticking with that.

MidCurrent Fly Fishing
Kirk Deeter is the editor of TROUT, the national publication of Trout Unlimited, and a frequent contributor to MidCurrent.
This article is filed under Experts with sub-topics , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Jim

    Interesting post.  I have a Sage LL 9′ 4 wt that I do 0o% of my trout fishing with.  I have the same rod in a 6wt that I rarely use, just doesn’t have that feel.

  • Bob

    Great post and so true. For me, it’s a 9 foot 7 weight Harry Murray Bass Rod made byScott. I find myself using that rod more and more – for smallmouth, streamer fishing for trout, and on the Finger Lake tribs. With it under arm, I feel powerful on the water…

  • Kholberg

    Suspect many keep buying the latest greatest searching for improvement in their skills. I remember Guy Clark in the 60’s had an old Harmony 12-string, sounded like a million bucks in his hands. We mere mortals think we need all the help we can get, that’s why we keep searching and spending.

  • wb

    Having played guitar for 27 years now, I find myself going through periods playing 1 guitar and 1 amp almost exclusively, for months or years at a time. Once you know what you are looking for, it is much easier to make your existing gear do what you want it to do.

  • Anonymous

    Being a person who enjoys comparisons and also things old, I’ll chose my rod based on the fishing situation. If doing more serious fishing like Lees Ferry or the San Juan the morecontemporary 9′ 5 wt would make most casts. If hitting the frequently stocked Salt River, Oak Creek, or Cottonwood Lagoon a light 3 wt is a lot more fun. In early spring on a fish and game club pond with fall stocked bows it’s fun to pull out the 40yr old glass, metal ferule, patched on guide, Eagle Claw and clicker $8 reel. It provides a huge smile factor when landing just about anything and is by far the most fun for the cost.